The Necromancy of Thay is a sealed spellbook in Baldur’s Gate 3, found in Act One in Ilyn Toth’s hidden lab under the Apothecary’s house in the Blighted Village. You open it with the Dark Amethyst from the Whispering Depths, then pass up to three saving throws (Wisdom DC 10, 15 and 20) to read it. Turning even one page gives you Speak with Dead as a free ritual, and finishing the book in Act Three with the Tharchiate Codex teaches Danse Macabre.
Your other choices are giving it to Astarion or Gale, or destroying it with Radiant damage. Each one changes companion approval, so it’s worth deciding before you touch the cover. Details below follow bg3.wiki, the community wiki, as of October 2026. Mild companion spoilers for Astarion and Gale follow.
Questions players ask about the book
“I let Astarion read it. Why is the quest still open?”
A GameFAQs thread asked exactly this after handing the book to Astarion. Replies explained that once a companion has the book, it stays with them and you can’t progress it further yourself. If you want Danse Macabre for your own character, keep the book and read it. One poster called it one of the game’s easiest quests to lock yourself out of, since a failed check, a lost book or a sale can all cause trouble.
“How do I get Gale to consume it?”
On the Larian Studios forums, a moderator’s answer was: put the amethyst in the book outside camp, give it to Gale in dialogue, and he’ll consume it the next time you’re at camp. Gale won’t explode. The catch: if any other character has already opened it, Gale can’t consume or read it. The wiki confirms that Gale eating it destroys the book with no benefit to you.
“There’s no option to give it to anyone”
A Larian forum thread from launch week had a player stuck with only read, destroy or put back. They had already slotted the stone in. Replies suggested trying to have Astarion in the party when you interact with it, since he’s the one who asks for it. Have the right companion with you when you first use the book, and don’t open it first if your plan is to give it away.
Where is the Necromancy of Thay in BG3?
It’s in Act One, in the Search the Cellar quest area:
- Go to the Apothecary’s house just south of the Blighted Village waypoint. Reading the Apothecary’s Ledger on the counter starts the quest.
- Open the wooden hatch behind the counter and go down to the cellar.
- Pull the lever hidden behind crates on the north wall. It opens a passage to an underground cemetery.
- Get past the Ornate Mirror. You can pass as Ilyn Toth (his name is in a journal you’ll find nearby; DC 15 Performance or DC 10 Deception), intimidate it at DC 15, or have a Barbarian smash it with a DC 15 Strength check. Wrong answers fire a flaming sphere for 2d6 fire damage.
- In the lab, the book sits on a trapped altar in the east wing.
The altar is trapped. To lift the book safely, swap it for an item of similar weight, spot and disarm the trap with a Perception check, disarm the two statues, or go turn-based and move everyone out of range before leaving turn-based mode.
How to get the Dark Amethyst
The book won’t open without the Dark Amethyst, which lies on the ground in the Whispering Depths near the Phase Spider Matriarch. There are two ways down, per the Unlock the Ancient Tome quest page:
- The well north of the Blighted Village waypoint. Pick the [INVESTIGATION] option to peer in, then climb down the bucket rope.
- The blacksmith’s basement north of the waypoint. Break the cracked north wall with force damage.
An Apprentice’s Pack in the cave hints at the stone’s spot, deeper in the west below the Matriarch’s webs. You can sneak past the spiders or fight them; killing the Matriarch drops the Poisoner’s Robe. Missed it entirely? A second Dark Amethyst sits on a desk in the basement of Philgrave’s Mansion in Act Three.
Reading the Necromancy of Thay: checks and rewards
With the book and amethyst in your party, use the book and choose to place the amethyst in the cover. Then you get up to three pages, each with a harder Wisdom saving throw. Some classes get easier alternatives:
| Page | Default | Bard | Sorcerer | Other options |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Wisdom save DC 10 | Performance DC 5 | Charisma DC 5 | Warlock: Charisma DC 5. Wizard: Intelligence DC 5 |
| 2 | Wisdom save DC 15 | Performance DC 10 | Charisma DC 10 | None |
| 3 | Wisdom save DC 20 | Performance DC 15 | Charisma DC 15 | Evil Cleric (including Shadowheart): Wisdom DC 10. Astarion: Wisdom DC 15 |
What you get:
- Speak with Dead, permanently, after one page. It’s cast as a ritual and costs no spell slot, which makes it handy for the many corpses with something to say.
- Forbidden Knowledge, a passive, after turning all three pages (pass or fail). You can trade it at the Mirror of Loss in the House of Grief for a permanent bonus without the usual cost.
Failing hurts but isn’t fatal. The first failure gives Whispers of Madness, which a long rest clears. A second gives Baleful Knowledge, which only Remove Curse fixes. Both give Disadvantage on Wisdom checks. Close the book early and you can come back to it later.
Approval for reading it: Gale −5, Astarion −1 and Karlach −1. Once you’ve read it, the book is bound to your inventory and nobody else can read it.
Give it to Astarion, give it to Gale, or destroy it?
Each choice has a clear trade-off:
| Choice | What happens | Approval |
|---|---|---|
| Read it yourself | Speak with Dead, Forbidden Knowledge, Danse Macabre later | Gale −5, Astarion −1, Karlach −1 |
| Give it to Astarion | Camp scene; he keeps it permanently | Astarion +5, Gale −5 |
| Let Gale consume it | Book is destroyed, you gain nothing from it | Not listed on the wiki |
| Destroy it | Three hostile Shadows appear | Lae’zel, Karlach and Wyll approve; Astarion −5, Gale −5 |
To destroy it, drop the book on the ground and hit it with Radiant damage, such as Guiding Bolt. Holy Water doesn’t work, and tossing it into a chasm just bounces it back to you. Be ready for a fight with the Shadows.
For most players, reading it is the strongest pick: Speak with Dead is free utility for the whole game, and Danse Macabre is a solid Act Three summon. Pick Astarion if you’re building his approval, especially since reading it costs only −1 with him.
Finishing the book in Act Three: Danse Macabre
After three pages the book stays shut until you find The Tharchiate Codex. It’s in the Sorcerous Vault under Sorcerous Sundries in the Lower City. Gale, Tolna Tome-Monger and Mystic Carrion (for 1,500 gp) can all point you to it.
Reading the Codex curses that character with Tharchiate Withering, which lowers Constitution. Remove Curse or Greater Restoration lifts it, and after that the Codex grants 20 temporary hit points after every long rest. The same reader then reopens the Necromancy of Thay and makes a final DC 20 Wisdom save. Pass or fail, they learn Danse Macabre; a failure just adds Baleful Knowledge.
Danse Macabre is a level 5 necromancy spell that summons 4 Ghouls (20 HP, 17 AC each) once per long rest. It doesn’t use a spell slot, despite what the tooltip says, and the Ghouls stay until your next long rest. You can’t control them, which some players dislike, but the Undead Thralls feature raises the count to 5. If Astarion holds the book, he can read both books to learn what his scars mean without Raphael’s help.
Frequently asked questions
Can you get Speak with Dead without passing every check?
Yes. Turning a single page of the Necromancy of Thay grants Speak with Dead permanently, and turning all three gives Forbidden Knowledge even if you fail the saves.
Does reading the Necromancy of Thay break a Paladin oath?
No, reading it doesn’t break the Oath of the Ancients.
Can you sell the Necromancy of Thay?
Selling it can lock you out of the quest. Players on GameFAQs warn that selling or losing the book is one of the easiest ways to ruin it, so keep it in a safe inventory slot.
What if I never found the Dark Amethyst in Act One?
You can still open the book. A second Dark Amethyst is on a desk in the basement of Philgrave’s Mansion in Act Three.
Who should read the Necromancy of Thay?
Pick the character with the best Wisdom save, or a Bard, Sorcerer or Warlock who gets easier checks. Whoever reads it is the only one who can finish it later with the Tharchiate Codex.
Featured image: Larian Studios
