There are 6 Pale Ore in Hollow Knight, and you need every one of them to reach the Pure Nail. You get them from the Ancient Basin (guarded by two Lesser Mawleks), the Seer at 300 Essence, the summit of Crystal Peak called Hallownest’s Crown, Nosk’s lair in Deepnest, the Grubfather after 31 Grubs, and the first clear of the Trial of the Conqueror. The Nailsmith in the City of Tears takes 1, then 2, then 3 Pale Ore for the last three upgrades.
Pale Ore is the only upgrade material for the Knight’s nail, so the usual problem isn’t finding the first piece. It’s working out which one you skipped when the Nailsmith says you’re short.
“I’m still one Pale Ore short”: what players ran into
“I beat Nosk but the Pale Ore is gone”
One player on the Hollow Knight Steam forum went back to Nosk’s arena five times and found nothing. Replies pointed to the cave just past the arena, where the ore sits in a fossil. When the player loaded a save file analyzer, it turned out the Nosk ore had already been picked up and two other pieces were missing. Someone in the thread also flagged the Grubfather piece as the one people forget. The lesson: count what you’ve actually spent at the Nailsmith before blaming a bug.
“Did I skip the Grubfather’s ore by leaving early?”
If you free a batch of grubs and rush out of the Grubfather’s room, you won’t lose the ore. A reply on Steam says simply, “You shouldn’t be able to miss it,” adding that an old version once let players skip a grub reward but that’s no longer possible. Go back and talk to him again.
“I rescued 31 grubs and got no ore”
In a Steam thread about exactly this, the reply was blunt: the player hadn’t really saved 31. There are 46 real Grubs, and the Grub Mimics in Deepnest and Crystal Peak don’t count. Check the counter in the Grubfather’s room rather than your memory.
“The guides list six places, but I only have five”
In another Steam discussion, a first-time player had visited every listed spot and was still one piece down. The tip that stood out: the Ancient Basin ore is easy to miss because its path starts to the left of the tram station, not near the main drop. If you’re one short, that’s the first place to double-check.
“I have Pale Ore but the upgrade won’t trigger”
This one is almost always the wrong NPC. In a Steam thread a player kept talking to Nailmaster Sheo, and the fix was a reminder that “Only Nailsmith can upgrade your weapon.” His hut is in the far west of the City of Tears.
Where to find all Pale Ore in Hollow Knight
All six Pale Ore locations come with a requirement, whether that’s an ability, Essence, Geo or Grubs. This table shows what each one asks of you, based on the Hollow Knight Wiki’s Pale Ore page and the linked area and NPC pages.
| # | Location | How you get it | What you need |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ancient Basin | Pick it up west of the tram station after beating two Lesser Mawleks | Access to the Basin (Royal Waterways bridge or the Tram Pass) |
| 2 | Seer, Resting Grounds | Reward for 300 Essence | Dream Nail and enough dreams collected |
| 3 | Hallownest’s Crown, Crystal Peak | Inside the Radiance statue at the summit | Monarch Wings (or advanced pogo tricks) |
| 4 | Nosk’s lair, Deepnest | In a fossil in the cave past the arena after you beat Nosk | Monarch Wings or Crystal Heart |
| 5 | Grubfather, Forgotten Crossroads | Reward for 31 rescued Grubs | 31 Grubs freed |
| 6 | Colosseum of Fools, Kingdom’s Edge | First clear of the Trial of the Conqueror | Trial of the Warrior done, 450 Geo fee |
1. Ancient Basin
The Ancient Basin page places this ore in the western part of the tram tunnel. In practice you head left from the tram station, deal with the two Lesser Mawleks guarding the spot, and grab it. You can reach the Basin across the collapsed bridge from the Royal Waterways or by riding the tram from Deepnest once you have the Tram Pass. Because it’s off to the side, this is the piece people most often walk past.
2. The Seer at 300 Essence
The Seer sits in the north of the Resting Grounds and hands out rewards as your Essence total climbs. Pale Ore is the 300 Essence reward, after the Hallownest Seal at 100 and the Spirits’ Glade at 200. Essence comes from hitting Whispering Roots with the Dream Nail, beating the warrior dreams at graves, and dream-nailing hidden things around the map. Clearing a couple of Whispering Roots is usually the fastest way to close the gap.
3. Hallownest’s Crown
The very top of Crystal Peak is Hallownest’s Crown, and the ore sits inside a statue of the Radiance looking down over Dirtmouth. The wiki lists Monarch Wings as the way up. Skilled players sometimes get there with only Mothwing Cloak and Mantis Claw by bouncing off Crystal Hunters and their shots, but that’s a tough route for a normal run. Get the wings first and this becomes a straightforward climb.
4. Nosk’s lair
Nosk lives at the bottom of Deepnest. Break the wall in the room just west of the Deepnest Hot Spring, which hides a Grub, then break the wall behind that Grub to reach the tunnels to the lair. You’ll need Monarch Wings or Crystal Heart for the hidden room. Nosk has 680 HP and charges straight through you, so keep jumping over it. After the fight, keep going past the arena: the ore is in a fossil in the next cave, not in the arena itself.
5. The Grubfather
The Grubfather is in the northwest corner of the Forgotten Crossroads. According to the Grub reward table, the 31st Grub you rescue earns the Pale Ore. Rewards depend on the total you’ve saved, not on which Grubs, so any 31 work. There are 46 Grubs in all.
6. Trial of the Conqueror
The Colosseum of Fools is at the top of Kingdom’s Edge, reached through a cavern in the northwest of the western chasm. The Trial of the Conqueror costs 450 Geo to enter and opens only after you beat the 100 Geo Trial of the Warrior. It runs 17 waves. Your first clear gives the Pale Ore plus roughly 2,000 Geo, which pays for a good chunk of the next upgrade. Repeat clears pay Geo only.
What is Pale Ore used for?
Pale Ore pays the Nailsmith for nail upgrades, and nothing else. The first upgrade needs only Geo; each one after that needs more ore. Figures come from the Hollow Knight Wiki’s Nail page.
| Upgrade | Damage | Geo | Pale Ore |
|---|---|---|---|
| Old Nail (start) | 5 | – | – |
| Sharpened Nail | 9 | 250 | 0 |
| Channelled Nail | 13 | 800 | 1 |
| Coiled Nail | 17 | 2,000 | 2 |
| Pure Nail | 21 | 4,000 | 3 |
That adds up to 7,050 Geo and all 6 Pale Ore for the Pure Nail. Since the Coiled Nail alone eats two pieces, it pays to save ore rather than chasing it one at a time: collect a couple, then visit the Nailsmith in the western City of Tears once you have the Geo as well.
Which Pale Ore should you go for first?
Start with whichever ones need the least. The Ancient Basin piece and the Seer’s 300 Essence reward ask for no late-game movement abilities, so they’re the natural first two and cover the Channelled Nail. Grubs build up as you explore, so 31 tends to arrive on its own around mid-game.
Leave the Crown and Nosk until you have Monarch Wings, and the Trial of the Conqueror until your nail and charms can handle 17 waves. The 2,000 Geo payout makes that trial a good one to time right before you buy the Pure Nail.
Is there Pale Ore in Hollow Knight: Silksong?
Not as an item. Silksong’s equivalent is Pale Oil, which you take to Pinmaster Plinney to upgrade Hornet’s Needle. There are three of them, two in the Citadel and one from the Flea Caravan in the Putrified Ducts. The wiki notes the only Silksong mention of the ore itself is flavour text: the Ancient Mask is described as carved from “cold, pale ore.”
Frequently asked questions
Can you miss Pale Ore in Hollow Knight?
No piece is permanently missable in the current version. All six stay available until you collect them, and a Steam reply notes that an older build let players skip a grub reward but that this was fixed.
Can you buy Pale Ore from a shop?
No. None of the six pieces is sold by a merchant. Each one comes from a fixed spot, a boss, an NPC reward or the Trial of the Conqueror.
Why won’t Sheo upgrade my nail?
Nailmaster Sheo teaches the Great Slash nail art, he doesn’t forge nails. Upgrades only come from the Nailsmith in the western part of the City of Tears.
Does Pale Ore do anything besides nail upgrades?
No. Its only use is paying the Nailsmith for the Channelled, Coiled and Pure Nail. Once you own the Pure Nail, extra ore has no purpose.
What happens to the Nailsmith after the Pure Nail?
Minor spoiler: he asks you to strike him down. Sparing him earns the Happy Couple achievement and he later turns up in Sheo’s hut in Greenpath, while killing him earns Purity. You can only get one of the two on a save.
Featured image: Team Cherry
